The NYSED website has identified the Niagara Falls City SD as having non-public school students within its authority. Every non-public school student in the Niagara Falls City SD area represents a school budget savings because this district is required to provide a basic education to these students should they return to Niagara Falls City SD.
Below are the 2013-2014 the budget savings that non-public school parents are providing every taxpayer in NYS and in the Niagara Falls City SD.
NYS resident tax savings provided by non-public school parents:
Niagara Falls City SD budget/enrollment with non-public school parents subsidizing the mandatory costs.
Niagara Falls City SD budget reflecting all non-public students returning for their rights to a basic public education:
Whether or not the number above is large or small, there are non-public schools across NY state subsidizing your local property and state income taxes by an estimated $11.4 billion dollars.
If you live in or near this district and the non-public school closes, you may wish something more had been done.
Many of the operators of the non-public schools have said that they will be closing more schools unless something is done. There is a bill called the Education Tax Credit that offers non-public school parents a small tuition assistance program of $500 plus allowances for people to donate to scholarship funds for students. Neither portion of the proposal involves a reduction in funding to the Niagara Falls City SD or any other public schools. This small amount of help may prevent school budget increases of 4,638% for parents and taxpayers in other districts. Call your Albany representatives to find out where they stand.
All numbers based on freely available information at the NYSED website and assume that students without a non public option will return to the local public option.
Below is a breakdown of teacher absence costs for the Niagara Falls City School District. These numbers were reported to various Federal and State agencies in 2011-2012. To our knowledge, they have never been compiled in this manner. The individual district results can vary widely with some being very normal and others seeming to be completely out of normal. In some cases, public school teachers may be very sick. In other cases where up to 100% of the teachers are taking 10+ days off, there may be a serious systemic problem. Statewide concerns should be addressed directly to NY education officials and legislators. Those results are far beyond what normal should be as the Charter school totals suggest. As always we encourage parents and taxpayers to share this information.
District 2011-2012 details:
The results below should be higher as they only include information on fulltime Niagara Falls City School District teacher absences. A more accurate and much larger number would also include absences of the administration and other employees plus other costs such as health/welfare insurance. Additionally, our breakdown is based on the reported number of “10 or more days” and does not include exact absences beyond 10 days or amounts for teachers taking less than 10 days. We ask that you treat these numbers as a starting point for a discussion with local district officials if you feel the Niagara Falls City School District results are abnormal.
|Item||Niagara Falls City SD||Statewide||Charter Schools|
|Student : Teacher Ratio||19:1||13:1||13:1|
|Avg. pay per day||$412.64||$385||$319|
|Teachers Absent 10+ days||24||68,387||462.42|
|% of teachers absent 10+ days||4.7%||33%||9.2%|
|*Cost of absences||$149,635||$421,739,779||**$2,156,981|
|*Absence costs as a percent of spending||0.1%||.08%||N/A|
|*** Classes contracted for but substituted||1,200||3,419,331||23,121|
Average private sector sick days taken: 4 days or less per year. USDOL 2013
* Includes costs for 10 days of salary, substitutes (NYC rate of $165 per day) + 2011 pension rate of 11.11% .
** Excludes pensions as most charter schools use 401k’s or do not report.
*** Based on 5 classes per day
Data Sources: US Dept Of Labor, NY State Education Department. All data compiled and totaled in MS Excel using simple math commands. If the numbers above contain significant “No Data” results, that is because the district or NYS did not report the information at the time the datasets were compiled.
Absenteeism group on Facebook
NY’s 2014-2015 budget includes the $2 billion Smart Schools Bond Act to be put before voters in the November 2014 election. Should it pass, Niagara Falls City School District will receive a proportional share of the $2 billion based on the proportion of total formula school aid the district receives.
To receive the funds, Niagara Falls City School District in the county of Niagara is required to submit a detailed plan to a state review board. In developing plans, the school district is required to consult with appropriate stakeholders, including Niagara Falls parents, teachers, students and Niagara Falls community members.
Niagara Falls 2014 enrollment: 6741 students
|Funding type||Formula Aid||Hardware/Software||Pre-k||Bond Allocation|
|State Total||$21,280,313,886||$85,204,216||$385,034,734||$2 Billion|
A significant problem with this bond is that a district might spend on getting broadband access and a few computers while another district may spend the money on building pre-k classroooms. There just isn’t enough money unless Niagara Falls City School District already has high speed access, pre-k and a somewhat robust technology department. Even then, the legacy costs of maintaining additional salaries, pensions, benefits and technology will belong to Niagara Falls taxpayers. Similarly, Obama’s Race to the top program required all sorts of added services while providing pennies per student. As with this bond, it was big on “progressive” ideas and short on methods to pay for and maintain it. In the end it will likely result in higher local property taxes and state taxes (AKA- state aid).
Every district is required to have a technology plan. Most districts put these documents online for public review. Within this document you can get a general idea of the district equipment, class types, personnel and costs. Once you know what your local district has and roughly how much it costs, the proposed bond allocation may seem pointless or a jackpot. Keep in mind, mandatory pre-k costs for some districts will absorb a significant portion of the allocation.
|2013 spending*||$1.5 million/yr||$920,000||$550,000|
|Bond allocation||$1.9 million||$444,0000||$1.1 million|
*Spending numbers taken from the district’s technology plan, which may or may not reflect actual dollar amounts spent. Dollar amounts have been rounded.
As you can tell, some districts will be shorted while others will see a onetime increase depending on their current formula aid from the state. In the end, everyone will pay for the borrowed money.
Find the Niagara Falls City School District technology plan with a pre-linked search at Bing.
The $2 billion Smart Schools Bond is set to be voted on in November 2014. That being said, Niagara Falls City School District parents, taxpayers and community members should pay close attention to what the district is planning to do with this money. You may find the media pushing the idea that everyone is getting a laptop while your district has to buy a building for mandatory preschool services and decides it needs to install video surveillance. Then again, you may wind up with a front door that will stop a tank. Every district has different needs.